Zacatecas 1883: The Bonilla Observation

Mexican astronomer José Bonilla photographed 447 objects crossing the face of the Sun at Zacatecas Observatory, creating some of the earliest UFO photographs. In 2011, UNAM researchers identified the objects as fragments of a comet that nearly struck Earth.

Original photograph from Bonilla observation showing objects crossing the Sun
AI visualization based on witness descriptions. This is a dramatization, not a photograph.
CASE IDUAPI-1883-001
DATEAugust 12, 1883
LOCATIONAstronomical Observatory, Zacatecas, Mexico
COORDINATES22.78°N 102.58°W
CLASSIFICATIONASTRONOMICAL-ANOMALY
EVIDENCE QUALITYHIGH
Mexican astronomer José Bonilla photographed 447 objects crossing the face of the Sun at Zacatecas Observatory, creating some of the earliest UFO photographs. In 2011, UNAM researchers identified the objects as fragments of a comet that nearly struck Earth.
447OBJECTS PHOTOGRAPHED

On August 12, 1883, José Bonilla, director of the Astronomical Observatory in Zacatecas, Mexico, was preparing his telescope for routine solar observation when he noticed objects partially blocking the Sun. Over the next 48 hours, Bonilla photographed 447 objects crossing the solar disk using the wet-plate collodion process, creating what are generally regarded as the first photographs of unidentified flying objects.

Bonilla described the objects as "fuzzy" or "misty" in nature, often with "dark tails." His photographs and detailed observations were published in the prestigious French astronomy journal L'Astronomie in January 1886. Editor Camille Flammarion, unable to identify the objects, speculated they might be birds, insects, or dust near the telescope.

In October 2011, researchers from the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) published a study identifying the objects as fragments of a comet that had broken apart and passed extremely close to Earth. Their calculations suggested the fragments were between 538 and 8,062 kilometers from the surface, and if they had struck Earth, the impact would have caused "3,275 Tunguska events in two days, probably an extinction event."

Support Independent UAP Research

Get exclusive case analyses, deep‑dive reports, and behind‑the‑scenes updates.

Subscribe on Gumroad ($5/month)

Historical Context

The Astronomical Observatory of Zacatecas was established in December 1882 atop La Bufa Hill. José Bonilla (1853-1920) was its first director, having been educated in engineering and astrophotography in Zacatecas, Mexico City, and Paris. The observatory was a legitimate scientific institution, and Bonilla was a credentialed professional astronomer.

The wet-plate collodion process Bonilla used was the standard photographic method of the era. It required coating glass plates with light-sensitive chemicals immediately before exposure and developing them while still wet. This process could capture rapid exposures (1/100 second), making it suitable for astronomical photography.

The 1880s were a period of active astronomical observation, but no technology existed that could produce the observed phenomenon artificially. Balloons existed but could not create hundreds of objects crossing the Sun's disk. The parallax effect noted in the 2011 study explains why only observers at Zacatecas latitude could see the objects.

Timeline

December 1882
Zacatecas, Mexico
Astronomical Observatory of Zacatecas opens with José Bonilla as first director [1]
August 12, 1883 - Morning
Zacatecas Observatory
Bonilla begins routine solar observation, notices objects crossing the Sun [2]
August 12-13, 1883
Zacatecas Observatory
Over 48 hours, Bonilla photographs 447 objects using wet-plate collodion process at 1/100 second exposure [2]
January 1, 1886
Paris, France
Observations published in L'Astronomie magazine; editor Camille Flammarion speculates objects are birds or insects [3]
1920
Mexico City
José Bonilla dies [1]
October 2011
Mexico City
UNAM researchers Manterola, Ramos Lara, and Cordero publish study identifying objects as comet fragments [4]

Witness Accounts

José A. y BonillaProfessional astronomer, Director of Zacatecas Observatory. Educated in engineering and astrophotography in Paris.[Employment and credentials verified through observatory records and L'Astronomie publication]
"[Observed] fuzzy or misty objects, often with dark tails, crossing the face of the Sun."
Original observation report published in L'Astronomie, January 1886 [2][3]

Physical and Documentary Evidence

Photographic
Wet-plate collodion photographs of 447 objects crossing the solar disk. Multiple exposures taken over 48 hours at 1/100 second exposure time. [2][3]
Status: Images published in L'Astronomie (1886). Reproductions widely available. Original plates presumed held at Zacatecas Observatory archives.
Documentary
Original observation report with detailed descriptions, timing data, and methodology published in L'Astronomie, the official journal of the French Astronomical Society. [3]
Status: Published January 1, 1886. Journal archived and accessible through astronomical archives.
Scientific Analysis
2011 UNAM study providing calculations of object distance (538-8,062 km), size (68-795 m), and identification as comet fragments. [4]
Status: Published as arXiv preprint (arXiv:1110.2798). Peer discussion in astronomy community.

Competing Explanations

Comet fragments passing close to Earth (2011 UNAM study) [4][5]

Supporting Evidence

UNAM researchers calculated objects were 538-8,062 km from Earth based on parallax and timing data. The "fuzzy" appearance and "dark tails" match comet fragment characteristics. Parallax explains why only Zacatecas-latitude observers saw the event. Mass calculations suggest original comet was comparable to Halley's Comet.

Conflicting Evidence

No independent corroboration from other observatories at same latitude. Some aspects of calculation rely on assumptions about Bonilla's timing accuracy.

Birds, insects, or atmospheric debris (Flammarion 1886) [3]

Supporting Evidence

Editor Camille Flammarion suggested objects might be nearby phenomena misperceived as distant. Birds or insects could produce silhouettes against the Sun.

Conflicting Evidence

The 48-hour observation period and 447 objects make insect/bird explanation implausible. Bonilla was an experienced astronomer who would recognize local debris. The "dark tails" are inconsistent with bird silhouettes.

Unidentified aerial phenomena [2][4]

Supporting Evidence

Before the 2011 study, the photographs were considered unexplained. The structured appearance and organized transit across the Sun suggested artificial objects to some researchers.

Conflicting Evidence

The 2011 comet fragment hypothesis provides a natural explanation consistent with all observed characteristics. Scientific consensus now favors the comet explanation.

Scientific Analysis

Investigating Bodies: French Astronomical Society (1886), UNAM (2011)
Methods: Initial publication and peer review by Camille Flammarion (1886). Modern analysis using parallax calculations, mass estimation, and trajectory modeling by Manterola et al. (2011)
Finding: Objects identified as fragments of a comet that broke apart and passed within hundreds to thousands of kilometers of Earth
Conclusion: The Bonilla observation represents authentic astronomical documentation of a near-Earth comet breakup event. The objects are no longer classified as unexplained. [4][5]
SOURCE LOG
[1]Imagen Zacatecas. "Conoce el talento de José Árbol y Bonilla." January 16, 2015. Biographical information on Bonilla.[secondary]
[2]Voisey, Jon. "Was the First Photographed UFO a Comet?" Universe Today, October 14, 2011.[secondary]
[3]L'Astronomie, January 1, 1886. Original publication of Bonilla observation with Flammarion commentary.[primary]
[4]Manterola, H.J.; Ramos Lara, M.; Cordero, G. "Interpretation of the observations made in 1883 in Zacatecas (Mexico): A fragmented comet that nearly hits the Earth." arXiv:1110.2798, October 2011.[primary]
[5]MIT Technology Review. "Billion-Ton Comet May Have Missed Earth by a Few Hundred Kilometers in 1883." October 17, 2011.[secondary]
[6]The Week. "Did a massive comet almost wipe out humans in 1883?" October 18, 2011.[secondary]
Editorial Note: This case represents one of the earliest photographic UFO cases in history. The original photographs and observation report are preserved and can be verified. The 2011 UNAM study provides a scientific explanation identifying the objects as comet fragments that passed dangerously close to Earth. This case demonstrates how rigorous analysis can resolve historical UFO cases while preserving their scientific value.